Topic Options
#684 - 07/17/99 10:56 AM Jack Attack
John Offline
Member

Registered: 04/26/99
Posts: 3124
Loc: Roanoke, VA, USA
My copy arrived yesterday afternoon. I have finished the first story and am attempting to resisit skipping directly to the title story, the subject of which I find of particular interest. I always assume, perhaps in correctly, that a short story compilation is ordered in a particular way and should be read in order.

Top
#685 - 07/19/99 08:54 AM Re: Jack Attack
Barbara Offline
Administrator

Registered: 04/24/99
Posts: 13033
Loc: Citrus Heights, CA , US
Sorry to be so slow answering, John; this is my first time online since I left Pittsburgh.

There's a rule of thumb for story order in anthologies: best story first, second-best story last, and third-best story as near to the middle as possible. It's a rule not slavishly adhered to, but it's a guideline most anthologists find helpful.

But that's anthologies, not single-author collections. This is my only experience with a collection and I don't know of any equivalent rule; the editor just left the order up to me. I tried to arrange the stories in a sequence that would make for agreeable reading for someone who's never read them before. I thought a "caper" story would be a good way to ease into the collection, and I didn't want to put something as light as "Ho Ho Ho" immediately after "Jack Be Quick", etc.

In other words, it's all guesswork -- like everything else in publishing.

Top
#686 - 07/19/99 09:34 AM Re: Jack Attack
John Offline
Member

Registered: 04/26/99
Posts: 3124
Loc: Roanoke, VA, USA
Well, in that case, perhaps I will skip directly to Jack . . . I wonder why publishing is so far behind other industries in micromanaging every aspect of it market . . . perhaps there is still some artistic sensibility in it?

Top
#687 - 07/19/99 01:16 PM Re: Jack Attack
Kay Offline


Registered: 04/25/99
Posts: 17046
Loc: Roanoke, VA , USA
So, based on that logic, my saving Barbara's contribution to "First Lady Murders" to last, means I am saving the best for last (which of course I knew already)

I've actually been skipping around and carefully putting off all the Edith Wilson stories to read together.

So, pray tell, how do we know which is the "worst" story?
_________________________
Kay
Botticelli Moderator

Top
#688 - 07/20/99 08:32 AM Re: Jack Attack
Barbara Offline
Administrator

Registered: 04/24/99
Posts: 13033
Loc: Citrus Heights, CA , US
Anthologists never admit there is a "worst" one, Kay. At least, not in public.

Top
#689 - 07/20/99 09:34 AM Re: Jack Attack
Kay Offline


Registered: 04/25/99
Posts: 17046
Loc: Roanoke, VA , USA
Presumably the really bad ones don't make the cut. Speaking "generally" here, as I am sure Barbara has never written a really bad story

And readers of anthologies, whether by the same author or by several, will have a "favorite" and probably find at least one they don't like.



[This message has been edited by Kay (edited 07-20-99).]
_________________________
Kay
Botticelli Moderator

Top
#690 - 07/21/99 03:07 PM Re: Jack Attack
John Offline
Member

Registered: 04/26/99
Posts: 3124
Loc: Roanoke, VA, USA
I did as I threatened and skipped to the end to read Jack. Great Story! Of course this raises my expectations for everything in between Sloshed Chicken and Jack :-)

Top
#691 - 07/22/99 09:53 AM Re: Jack Attack
Barbara Offline
Administrator

Registered: 04/24/99
Posts: 13033
Loc: Citrus Heights, CA , US
Thanks, John; glad you liked it. What's in between the two end stories is a smorgasbord. "Samplings", let's call them.

I mentioned in the intro that I don't think any of the usual suspects was the Ripper. I suspect his real name never even came up during that exhaustive investigation.

Top
#692 - 07/22/99 05:42 PM Re: Jack Attack
John Offline
Member

Registered: 04/26/99
Posts: 3124
Loc: Roanoke, VA, USA
I remember hearing about a story were the Ripper was Jill, not Jack. Con't recall when or where though. Anyone ever read that one?

Top
#693 - 07/22/99 07:47 PM Re: Jack Attack
Jon Offline


Registered: 04/25/99
Posts: 6422
Loc: Newark, Delaware, USA
I just finished the last story (Jack) today; I've been forcing myself to space out the experience more than I usually would (I tend to devour books), to prolong the pleasure. I read it all in order, like the nice well-raised boy that I am.

I loved 'em all. Lovely variety and contrast from one to the next. I will venture to say that, although I enjoyed "French Asparagus" as much as the others, I'm worried that I didn't get everything in it. Is there an unspoken undertone that I'm somehow missing? I'm nervous about possibly having missed the significance of asparagus here.

Top

Moderator:  Barbara